Moral compensation for road traffic accidents victims in Algeria: A comparative study with Egyptian and Jordanian Law
Keywords:
Moral compensation, liability, Moral damage, Rightful claimants, Road accidents victims, Comparative legislationAbstract
The issue of compensation for moral damages for road accidents victims is considered one of the delicate matters within the scope of civil liability, given its connection to non-material interests that affect human dignity, sentiments, and feelings. Although the Algerian legislator has dedicated clear and independent provisions to regulate this type of damage, while referring to the established principles of compensation within the general rules of tort liability outlined in Article 124 and subsequent articles of the Civil Code, analysis has shown that Law 88-31 often tends to restrict the awarding of moral compensation. This is evident both in terms of limiting the beneficiaries—where it is confined to the rightful claimants of the victim in case of death—and in terms of assessing its value, especially when compared to comparative legislation such as Jordanian and Egyptian law, which adopt more flexible and humane approaches. The study concluded that legislative amendments are necessary to establish objective criteria for assessing moral compensation and to expand the range of its beneficiaries. This would achieve a balance between the aggrieved party and the party causing the harm, and would enshrine the principle of justice and the protection of human dignity in the Algerian legal system.
Downloads
References
Ibrahim al-Sayyid Ahmad, Moral Damage in Jurisprudence and Case Law, 1st ed., Modern University Office, Cairo, 2008.
Ibrahim al-Sayyid Ahmad, Civil Liability, Legal Books House, Cairo, 2006.
Ahmad Shawqi Abd al-Rahman, Research Studies in Civil Liability, Knowledge Establishment House, Alexandria, 1st ed., 2007.
Idris Fadli, The Concise Guide to the General Theory of Obligation, University Publications Office, First Edition, Algeria, 2006.
Anwar al-Amrusi, Commentary on the Amended Civil Code Texts, no publisher, 1993.
Larbi Belhaj, The General Theory of Obligation in Algerian Civil Law, Part 01, Ben Aknoun, Algeria, 2001.
Jalal Ali al-Adawi, Sources of Obligation: A Comparative Study in Egyptian and Lebanese Law, University House, 1994.
Zahia Houria Si Youssef, Civil Liability of the Producer, Huma House for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, Algeria, 2009.
Hussein Amer and Abd al-Rahim Amer, Tort and Contractual Civil Liability, Second Edition, Dar al-Ma'arif, Egypt, 1979.
Hassan Ali al-Dhunun, The Detailed Explanation of Civil Law: Damage, Wael House, Jordan, 2006.
Sulayman Marqus, Provisions of Obligation in Tort, Legal Book House, Cairo, 1998.
Abd al-Aziz al-Lasasmah, Theory of Obligations in Light of Jordanian Civil Law, International Scientific House for Publishing and Distribution, Lebanon, 2002.
Abd al-Hakam Fuda, Civil Compensation: Contractual and Tort Liability, University Thought House, Cairo, 2004.
Abd al-Razzaq al-Sanhuri (n.d.), The Intermediary in Explaining the New Civil Code: The General Theory of Obligation, Evidence, Effects of Obligation, Part One, House of Revival of Arab Heritage, Beirut, 1963.
Abd al-Wahhab Arafa, The Intermediary in Civil Compensation for Civil Liability, University Press House, Cairo, 2004.
Omar Basem Nayef, Assessment of Compensation for Variable Damage: A Comparative Study, New University House, Egypt, 2022.
Ali Filali, Obligations: The Act Deserving Compensation, Mofem for Publishing and Distribution, 2nd ed., 2007.
Muhammad Hussein Mansour, Theory of Right, Knowledge Establishment House, Alexandria, 1998.
Muhammad Husam Mahmoud Lutfi, The General Theory of Obligation, Dar al-Salam Press, Cairo, 2007.
Nabil Ibrahim Saad, The General Theory of Obligation: Provisions of Obligation, New University House, Egypt, 2009.
Nabil Saqr et al., The Scientific Guide for Lawyers - Drafting Petitions - Insurance and Traffic Accidents in Jurisprudence and Practice, Layma House Publications, 2025.
Youssef Delenda, The System of Compensation for Bodily and Material Damages Resulting from Traffic Accidents, Huma House for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, Algeria, 2012.
Said Muqaddam, Compensation for Moral Damage: A Comparative Study, Master's Thesis in Contracts and Liability, Institute of Law and Sciences, University of Algiers, 1992.
Sanaa Khamis, Strict Liability of the Producer as a Compensation Mechanism for Victims of Defective Product Accidents: A Comparative Study, Master's Thesis in Contract Law, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Mouloud Mammeri University, Tizi Ouzou, Algeria, 2015.
Briq Rahma, Dellaj Muhammad al-Khadr, Compensation for Moral Damage in the Scope of Civil Liability and Criteria for Its Assessment, Journal of Law and Political Sciences, Volume 06, Issue 02, Algeria, 2020.
Murad Fadl bin Abdullah Abduhu, Monetary Inflation and Its Impact on Wages and Debts, Jordanian Journal of Islamic Studies, Al al-Bayt University, Volume 15, Issue 1, 2019.
Muhammad al-Arusi Mansouri, Fatima Amal Halloush, Transfer of the Right to Compensation to Heirs in the Scope of Compensation for Moral Damage, Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, University of Sidi Bel Abbes (Algeria), Issue 1, 2021.
May Mashhour al-Jazi, The Position of the Jordanian Legislator in Assessing Compensation for Moral Damage, University Journal for Legal Studies, 2004.
Huda Abdullah, Lessons in Civil Law: Unlawful Acts, Halabi Legal Publications, Lebanon, 2008.
Yabdiri Rabia and Abdellaoui Khadija, "The Emergence of the Right to Compensation for Aggravated Damage within the Framework of Civil Liability," Journal of Law and Human Sciences, Volume 17, Issue 2, July 17, 2024.
Younes Khaled, The Nature of Evidence and Its Place in Algerian Civil Law and Judiciary, Horizons for Science Journal, Volume 3, Issue 4, September 1, 2018.
Order No. 74-15 dated January 30, 1974, concerning compulsory motor vehicle insurance and the system of compensation for bodily damages, Official Gazette No. 15 issued on February 19, 1974, amended and supplemented by Law 88-31 dated July 19, 1988, Official Gazette No. 29 issued on July 20, 1988.
Order No. 75-58, dated September 26, 1975, containing the Algerian Civil Code, Official Gazette No. 78 of 1975.
Jordanian Civil Code No. 43, Official Gazette No. 2663 dated August 1, 1976.
Egyptian Civil Code No. 131, issued on October 15, 1948.
Philip Étourneau, droit de la responsabilité, DALLOZ, 1996, p. 194.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 The International tax journal

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.


